HireOrSell logo
All articles
Guides & examples

What a 15% discount really costs

A 15% discount takes far more than 15% off your profit. See the extra volume you must sell to recover it at 50%, 40% and 25% margins, and when it can never be recovered.

Cover graphic titled What a 15% discount really costs

A 15% discount sounds like a 15% smaller profit. It is usually much worse, because the discount comes off your margin, not off your revenue. This post computes the extra work you must sell just to end up where you started.

Start with one hour

Say you sell an hour of work for $100 and it costs you $60 to deliver. Your margin on that hour is $100 - $60 = $40, which is 40% of the price.

Now give a 15% discount. The price becomes $100 x 0.85 = $85. The cost is still $60, because the work is the same. The margin is $85 - $60 = $25.

You gave up $15 of price, but you lost $15 of the $40 profit. That is 15 / 40 = 37.5% of your profit on every hour, from a discount that sounded like 15%.

How much more must you sell

To make the same total profit, you need more hours. Divide the old margin per hour by the new one: $40 / $25 = 1.6. You must sell 1.6 times as many hours, which is 60% more volume.

Here it is as a monthly example. Say you sell 100 hours at $100:

  • Before the discount: revenue 100 x $100 = $10,000. Cost 100 x $60 = $6,000. Profit $4,000.
  • After the discount, same 100 hours: revenue 100 x $85 = $8,500. Cost $6,000. Profit $2,500.
  • Hours needed to get back to $4,000: $4,000 / $25 = 160 hours. Revenue 160 x $85 = $13,600. Cost 160 x $60 = $9,600. Profit $4,000.

Revenue went from $10,000 to $13,600 and the profit did not move. That is a lot of extra work for no gain.

The formula

You do not have to redo the table every time. If the discount is d and your margin is m, both as shares of the original price, the extra volume needed is:

d / (m - d)

For this example, 0.15 / (0.40 - 0.15) = 0.15 / 0.25 = 0.60, or 60% more volume. It matches the table above.

The same 15% at different margins

The thinner your margin, the worse a discount gets. Using a $100 price and 15% off:

  • 50% margin (cost $50): new margin is $85 - $50 = $35. Extra volume: 0.15 / 0.35 = 43%. Check: $50 / $35 = 1.43.
  • 40% margin (cost $60): new margin $25. Extra volume: 60%.
  • 25% margin (cost $75): new margin $85 - $75 = $10. Extra volume: 0.15 / 0.10 = 150%. Check: $25 / $10 = 2.5, so 2.5 times the volume.
  • 15% margin (cost $85): new margin $85 - $85 = $0. No amount of extra volume ever recovers the profit, because each additional hour earns nothing.

At a 25% margin, a 15% discount asks you to sell two and a half times as much work. For a small team, that may be more than it can deliver. Your capacity may be the limit before demand is.

A discount on a retainer

Say a client pays a $2,000 monthly retainer and asks for 15% off. The discount is $2,000 x 0.15 = $300 a month, or $300 x 12 = $3,600 a year.

If delivering the retainer costs you $1,200 a month (a 40% margin on $2,000, with $800 profit), the discounted fee is $1,700 and the profit is $1,700 - $1,200 = $500. Profit falls by $300 out of $800, which is 37.5%. Over a year the profit goes from $9,600 to $6,000.

Unless the discount gets you more work from that client, you now earn $3,600 a year less for the same effort. If it also frees you to take on new work, the calculation changes, but only if you actually have the new work.

Cheaper ways to win the deal

You do not always have to cut the price. Options that cost you less:

  • A smaller discount for a commitment. A 5% reduction for a 12-month term needs 0.05 / (0.40 - 0.05) = 14% more volume at a 40% margin. That is far easier to earn back, and the term itself is worth something.
  • Reduce scope instead of price. If the client's budget is $8,500 for work you priced at $10,000, remove 15% of the work. Your margin stays whole.
  • Add a payment term. Payment up front can be worth something to you without touching the margin per hour.
  • Offer a pilot. A smaller first project at full price, with a path to more.

Each of these keeps the price per hour intact, which keeps your rate card believable for the next client. For a view of what one fixed price actually earns when hours run over, see A fixed-price overrun: what a $10,000 project really earns.

Can you actually find the extra volume

The formula tells you what you would need. Whether you can get it is a separate question. Ask:

  1. Do I have spare capacity for 60% more work from this client or others?
  2. Is the demand there? Working back from a revenue goal shows the number of leads that extra volume requires, as in How many leads you need: working back from a revenue goal.
  3. Does the discounted client's new price become their reference point at renewal?

If the answer to any of these is no, the discount is a pure cost.

Your margin on delivery also depends on whether your own hours are billable. If you hire help to meet the extra volume, Break-even hourly rate with a part-time contractor shows what the new hours must earn to pay for themselves.

Put the terms in writing

When you do give a discount, write down what it buys. A short scope document that lists what is included, the review limit and the term keeps the discount from turning into an open-ended favor. Retainer scope template can be a starting point.

All figures above are hypothetical examples. Your costs and margins will differ.

Next step

Work out your real margin per hour on your last three projects. Put it into d / (m - d) with the discount a client is asking for, and decide before the next negotiation how much extra volume you would need to see.

Free plan available

Ready to run it all in one place?

Projects, clients, time tracking and invoicing in one platform.