HireOrSell logo
All articles
Projects & operations

5 signs your agency has outgrown spreadsheets

Spreadsheets work until they do not. Five signs your agency has hit the limit, each with a quick test you can run this week and an honest note on when to stay put.

Cover graphic titled 5 signs your agency has outgrown spreadsheets

Spreadsheets are a fine way to start an agency. They are flexible, free and familiar. The trouble arrives slowly, as more people, clients and dates pile into the same files. Here are five signs it is time to move, each with a test you can run in a few minutes.

Sign 1: Two people edit and nobody trusts the latest copy

You see file names like "tracker final" and "tracker final v2", or someone asks "which one is current" before every meeting.

The test: search your shared drive for your main tracker. Count how many versions exist. If there is more than one that people actually use, you have a version problem. Then ask two team members to read out the number of open projects. If their answers differ, the file is no longer a single source of truth.

Sign 2: You cannot say what is unbilled in five minutes

Work is done, hours are logged somewhere, and invoicing waits for someone to piece it together.

The test: set a timer for five minutes and try to answer, "How many hours were worked last week that are not on an invoice yet?" If you cannot, billable work can slip through.

This is a direct cost. If 2 hours a week go unbilled at $110 an hour, that is 2 times $110, which is $220 weekly, or $11,440 over 52 weeks. The figures are an example, but the check is worth running on your own numbers. Billing from project progress is covered in how to invoice from milestones and get paid faster.

Sign 3: The same client lives in several places

A client's contact is in the sales sheet, the project list and someone's email. Updating one leaves the others wrong.

The test: pick one client and list every file or tool that holds their contact, status or contract date. If the count is three or more, count how long it takes to change a phone number everywhere. Write down the number of places and the minutes. That is the cost of every future change.

Sign 4: One person is the system

One person understands the formulas, the color codes and the naming habits. When they are away, work slows.

The test: ask what would happen if that person were away for two weeks. If the honest answer is "invoices would not go out" or "nobody knows which deadlines are where", the system depends on one person's memory. Also check for formulas that break when someone inserts a row, or tabs nobody dares to touch.

Sign 5: Deadlines live in people's heads

Deadlines and meetings sit in separate calendars, a chat thread and a spreadsheet column. A date shifts in one place and not the others.

The test: choose one live project and list its next three deadlines from memory, then check them against every source. If two sources disagree, or someone has to ask in chat, a missed date is a matter of time.

Score yourself

Count how many tests failed.

  • 0 or 1: your spreadsheets are doing the job. Add a simple naming rule and a single owner for each file, and carry on.
  • 2 or 3: pain is real, but contained. Fix the worst one first, whichever costs you the most.
  • 4 or 5: you are losing time and money regularly. A move to a connected system is worth the effort.

Put a number on the time lost. Say four people spend 30 minutes each week reconciling files. That is 4 times 30, which is 120 minutes, or 2 hours a week. Over 52 weeks it is 104 hours. Multiply that by your own hourly cost to see what the habit costs.

Before you move anything

Spend an hour listing what your spreadsheets actually do. Write one line per file: what it holds, who updates it, who reads it and how often. You may find that a few files do the real work and others are never opened. Move the working ones and archive the rest. This list also becomes your requirements when you look at tools, so you judge each against your own needs and not against a feature list.

When to stay with spreadsheets

A system is not always the answer. Stay put if:

  • You are one or two people with a handful of clients.
  • Your problems are about habits, not tools, such as not logging time at all.
  • You have no time to migrate this quarter. A rushed move is worse than a slow one.

Spreadsheets also remain useful alongside any system for ad hoc analysis.

What a move looks like

If you decide to change, keep it small. Move one function first, such as time and invoicing, then clients, then projects. Agree on one place where each kind of information lives.

HireOrSell is one option built for agencies and service businesses. It combines project management, CRM, time tracking and invoicing in one place, and has a Free plan limited to 2 team members, 100 contacts and 3 projects, without time tracking. Check the pricing page for current plans. A team that needs only one narrow function, such as a CRM for a large sales team, may be better served by a specialist tool.

Next step

Run the five tests this week and write down the score. If it is 2 or more, pick the single failing test that costs you the most and fix that first.

Free plan available

Ready to run it all in one place?

Projects, clients, time tracking and invoicing in one platform.